Discover Old Town Suites in Key West, FL—a highly rated 4.2-star retreat featuring cozy cottages with kitchens, spacious rooms, and unbeatable central location. Enjoy friendly service, nearby attractions, and business amenities for a seamless stay.
Visitors appreciate the clean, well-appointed accommodations in a central Key West location, with easy access to local attractions and dining. Some note communication and parking can be challenging, but overall the setting and amenities receive positive feedback.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Old Town Suites offers an inviting retreat in the heart of Key West, perfectly blending comfort with convenience. Located at 517 Truman Ave, it provides guests with immediate access to the vibrant life of the old town while maintaining a quiet, welcoming atmosphere. With a solid rating of 4.2, this brand consistently meets the expectations of travelers seeking a genuine Key West experience.
Guests appreciate the brand's straightforward pricing, with room rates presented upfront, avoiding unexpected fees common in resort stays. The accommodations range from cozy rooms to charming cottages, featuring firm yet comfortable beds, spacious showers, and well-equipped kitchens. This attention to detail creates a satisfying home-away-from-home feel that enhances the overall stay.
The cottages stand out for their thoughtful design—large king beds, en suite bathrooms, dining areas, and cozy lounges provide ample space for relaxation. Many guests highlight the strong, reliable WiFi and the convenience of a front porch and nearby parking, though parking availability can be challenging in Key West. Nevertheless, the option to purchase parking spots on-site brings relief, especially given the scarcity of street parking.
Service plays a crucial role in the Old Town Suites experience. The staff, including the manager and housekeeping team, are known for their friendliness and helpfulness, readily offering local recommendations and enhancing visitors' plans with insider tips. This personalized touch fosters a genuine connection between guests and the historic surroundings.
Positioned within walking distance to many key attractions and essentials—such as a CVS across the street—the location proves unbeatable for exploring the rich culture and lively energy of Key West. Whether guests choose to rent scooters or bikes, the setting offers easy access to popular tourist destinations, restaurants, and outdoor activities that embody the island’s spirit.
Old Town Suites not only delivers a clean, comfortable place to rest but also offers an immersive experience rooted in authentic local charm. It’s a place where guests feel both grounded and free to explore, with every detail thoughtfully curated to make their stay memorable.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Perfect for what I needed in a last minute stay. The price for the room is up front, rather than usual resort fee upon arrival. There is a charge for parking. Previous reviews state $20. I was offered parking for $30, so I passed on it. The room is perfect for what I need. The bed is firm but not uncomfortably so. The shower is large and can accommodate tall people. I love the small kitchen and half size fridge and freezer. And the location is perfect for me. Also I keep weird hours sometimes since I'm a night shifter, so the self check in process was also great for me. Also, I saw reviews that sound there was a lot of noise in this room. I sleep with a low level of music. I hear some noise, but nothing keeping me from sleeping. Maybe it's just because I'm used to noise when I sleep since I usually sleep during the day anyway. Didn't annoy me much. One thing that caught me off guard was this rule about towels. It states to not use any towel to remove make up. They will charge you for towels, bed sheets, and wash clothes.... which is their right but I wish I would have known about that policy up front so I could have bought a towel before my arrival. I have vividly dyed hair which tends to bleed occasionally on towele after a shower. I've never ruined a towel at home but if makeup is a problem, I'm over paranoid about my hair being a problem. Again, if I had realized the policy before, I think I could have been prepared and dealt with if. Luckily though they provided a hair dryer so I just had to take some extra time to be sure. I would and probably will stay here again. Just will be more prepared next time!
Stayed here on vacation. We got the cottage, which was adorable. The place was really nice and clean. Lots of room. The manager Bob, and housekeeper Jelena were super friendly and helpful. Nice location. Walking distance to most things. Parking is a nightmare in key West. So probably worth the $20 to pay for the parking spot they offer their guests. There is free parking on the street, but very difficult to get, and if you do find a free parking spot, Don't move your car.
Gorgeous and well appointed cottage right in the centre of town - precisely where you need to be for Key West. Great value for money too. The cottage had a huge king-bed, en suite bathroom, kitchen, dining area and large lounge. There’s also good WiFi, a lovely porch and parking right outside the home. Across the road is a CVS for all the essentials (don’t go to the expensive little grocery store which charges tourists more!), also across the road is a bike hire place and a Cuban cafe next door. Duval Street is on the other side of the block, and the amazing waterfront is 15 minutes walk. You can also benefit from the little beach at the southernmost point which is less than 10 minutes walk from the cottage. Only constructive feedback is the communication from the owners wasn’t great - we didn’t get the door code until asking for it, and there’s very little information in the home so you have to do all your own research. Hopefully this review will provide useful information for anyone looking to book!
Perfect location. Extremely clean and owners were very accommodating and informative. Suggested places to eat and visit, including maps. Highly recommend!! This was our first time to Key West. We rented a scooter one day and bikes another. We loved our time there!
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Discover Aqua Inn Motel in El Monte, offering airconditioned rooms with free WiFi, accessible facilities, and free parking. Idea...
Experience cozy rooms with free WiFi and parking at Kay's Motel, located near Long Beach’s top attractions like The Queen Mary. F...
Experience comfort and warm hospitality at invitationNYC / AL Shami 408, located at 408 W 36th St. Enjoy a spotless, safe stay nea...
Experience clean, cozy rooms at Parkway Inn in Eugene, Oregon. Enjoy free WiFi, free parking, air conditioning, and familyfriend...
Wilshire Serrano Motel offers clean, airconditioned rooms with free WiFi and parking in a safe LA neighborhood. Steps from metro...
Bay Breeze Inn offers clean, spacious rooms with free WiFi and parking. Located near the Bishop Museum of Science and Nature, thi...
Adobe Inn Motel offers comfortable, budgetfriendly rooms in Clint, Texas. Enjoy free WiFi, ample parking, air conditioning, and ...
Discover Hotel Adamex Deming, a welcoming 3.5star hotel in Deming, NM, offering clean rooms with kingsized beds, free WiFi, and...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
